Industry · Telecom and subscriptions

Don't offer a discount to someone whose calls keep dropping.

Telecom and subscription companies measure churn more closely than anyone. They also know, from their own experiments, that contacting the wrong customer can make them leave.

The relationship

A monthly bill, and a relationship that changes underneath it.

The customer pays the same amount each month while their life changes: they move, add a line, travel, run into a network problem. Each change shows up somewhere in the company's data. Retention teams usually see a churn score.

The contract or promotion ends

The bill goes up, and the customer starts comparing.

Service gets worse

Dropped calls at home, a slow connection after a move, an outage in their area.

Bill shock

Roaming, an overage, a price rise. One bad bill can undo years.

Repeated calls to support

The same issue, three calls, three different agents.

A payment fails

Many subscription cancellations are a failed card, not a decision.

Usage drops

Fewer logins, fewer shows watched, a line that hasn't been used in weeks.

Usage examples

Same moment. Different decision.

Flip the switch: what a rule does today, then what one customer's agent would do.

Churn score crosses a threshold

A discount for everyone over the line

What a rule doesSends a retention offer to everyone above the line.

Fix the network before any offer

What the agent doesChecks why this customer is at risk. If it's network quality, it opens a fix first. If an outage is still open, it waits.

Contract ends next month

The same upgrade push for all

What a rule doesGeneric "upgrade now" campaign.

The plan that fits, even if cheaper

What the agent doesLooks at how this customer actually uses the plan, and proposes the plan that fits, even when it's cheaper.

Third support call about the same fault

Each call starts from scratch

What a rule doesEach call is handled separately.

The next agent already knows

What the agent doesBriefs the next support agent with the full history and flags it to a team lead before the customer has to explain again.

Card payment fails

Reminders on a fixed schedule

What a rule doesAutomated dunning emails on a fixed schedule.

A reminder timed to when they pay

What the agent doesTimes the reminder to when this customer usually pays, and holds any marketing until the payment is sorted.

Systems it reads

Where the history lives, and where decisions land.

The signals that predict who leaves are spread between billing, the network and the contact centre.

Reads Systems of record

  • Billing and charging: plans, bills, contract end dates, payments
  • CRM and customer care: support tickets and contact-centre notes
  • Network and usage data: dropped calls, speeds, outages by area, data use
  • App and web events: logins, plan views, cancellation-page visits
  • Retail and point of sale: store visits, device purchases

Writes Narrowly, to tools that act

  • Care brief: a note on the customer record for the next support agent
  • Retention offer list: add or hold a customer, with the reason
  • Ticket: a network or billing fix that has to come before any offer

Named products are examples of systems common in this industry, not finished connectors. See how Keepara connects.

Worked scenarios

Two customers, two jobs.

One high-value customer, where the agent briefs your team. One customer about to leave, where it proposes a careful step or decides to wait. Companies, people and figures are invented.

High-value customerIllustrative scenario

A small business with eight lines and home broadband

A family-run accounting firm with eight mobile lines, office broadband and the owner's home broadband, with the same provider for nine years (illustrative).

What the agent holds about this customer, and only this customer

WhatDetailWhere it comes from
SpendEight lines and two broadband connections on one accountBilling
Recent troubleTwo broadband outages at the office in the last quarter, one during the firm's busiest weekNetwork data, support tickets
ContractBusiness contract ends in ten weeksBilling
ContactThe office manager handles everything; the owner signs the contractCRM

How it's handled today

The account is in the business renewal queue, which a business account manager works through in contract-end order.

What the agent does

Brief for the business account manager

  1. Nine years with us, eight lines and two broadband connections.
  2. Two office outages last quarter, one in their busiest week. Both tickets closed without a follow-up.
  3. Contract ends in ten weeks. Suggest: call the office manager about the outages and the backup options before renewal comes up. The owner signs.

What it never does alone

It does not change prices or contract terms, and it does not contact the firm itself.

How results are measured

  • Renewal rate for business accounts the agent briefed on, against similar accounts it did not.
  • Revenue per account over the next contract.
Customer about to leaveIllustrative scenario

A customer whose calls drop at home after a move

A mobile customer of six years who moved house four months ago (illustrative).

What the agent holds about this customer, and only this customer

WhatDetailWhere it comes from
The changeNew billing address four months agoBilling
Since the moveDropped calls in the evenings, at the new address, several times a weekNetwork data
SupportTwo calls about poor signal. Told to restart the phoneContact-centre notes
ContractEnds in six weeks. Visited the cancellation page twiceBilling, app events
OffersHas not taken a promotional offer in six yearsCRM

How it's handled today

The churn model flags the customer as high risk. The retention campaign sends a discount on the current plan.

What the agent does

It decides a discount is the wrong step. The customer has reported poor indoor signal. The first step is to help with that problem.

Proposed for approval

  1. Open a network ticket for the new address.
  2. Offer help setting up Wi-Fi calling, if their phone supports it, in a short message: "I’m following up on the signal problems you reported. If your phone supports Wi-Fi calling, I can help you set it up while our network team investigates."
  3. Hold the retention offer until the signal is fixed.

What it never does alone

It does not offer discounts on its own, and its messages mention nothing about the customer beyond the service the company provides them.

How results are measured

  • Among flagged customers, the agent acts for a random half and the usual process handles the other half. Compare how many are still customers three months after contract end.
  • Track separately the customers where the agent chose to wait.
Notes and sources
  • In a mobile phone field experiment, 10% of customers offered a cheaper plan left within three months, compared with 6.4% in the control group. Ascarza, Iyengar and Schleicher, 2016.
  • In two field experiments, the customers most likely to leave were not always the ones most likely to respond to a retention offer. Ascarza, 2018.
  • Both customers are invented. No figures on this page are results.
Get in touch

No one wants to be a number in your database.

In 30 minutes, I’ll walk you through a customer example from your industry. We’ll discuss where it could help your team.